INDUS WATER TREATY b/w PAKISTAN VS INDIA

 

Indus Waters Treaty: India vs Pakistan – Cooperation or Conflict?

Water, one of the most essential resources for human survival, has long been a source of both collaboration and contention between nations. For India and Pakistan—two nuclear-armed neighbors with a complex and often hostile relationship—the sharing of the Indus River system has been a cornerstone of diplomatic engagement, even during times of military conflict.

Background: What is the Indus Waters Treaty?

Signed in 1960 and brokered by the World Bank, the Indus Waters Treaty (IWT) is one of the most enduring and successful water-sharing agreements in the world. It governs the use of waters from the six rivers of the Indus River system:

• Western Rivers: Indus, Jhelum, and Chenab (allocated to Pakistan)

• Eastern Rivers: Ravi, Beas, and Sutlej (allocated to India)

Under the treaty:

• India has control over the eastern rivers, but must allow unrestricted flow of the western rivers to Pakistan.

• India is permitted limited use of the western rivers for non-consumptive purposes like irrigation, hydropower, and transport, under strict technical limitations.

Why Was the Treaty Needed?

At Partition in 1947, the headwaters of the Indus system fell within Indian territory, while most of the rivers flowed into Pakistan. This geographical situation created an urgent need to define water rights, as water is vital for agriculture, especially in arid and semi-arid regions of both countries.

India’s Perspective

India views the treaty as overly generous to Pakistan. Despite controlling the headwaters, India is required to let about 80% of the total Indus water flow to Pakistan. Indian concerns include:

• Underutilization of permissible rights on western rivers due to technical and legal complexities.

• Delays caused by Pakistan's objections to Indian hydroelectric projects (e.g., Kishanganga, Ratle), which stall energy development.

• A belief that Pakistan uses the treaty as a political tool, rather than a cooperative framework.

India has occasionally threatened to revisit or suspend parts of the treaty in response to cross-border terrorism or political tensions, although such steps have not been officially implemented.

Pakistan’s Perspective

For Pakistan, the Indus River system is a lifeline—over 90% of its agricultural economy relies on these waters. Its concerns include:

• Indian hydroelectric projects possibly affecting downstream flow and harming Pakistan’s irrigation.

• A fear that India could use water as a strategic weapon during times of war or conflict.

• Legal and diplomatic channels being slow and unfavorable when it challenges Indian projects.

Pakistan argues that India sometimes violates the spirit of the treaty, even if technically within its rights.

Disputes and Resolutions

While the treaty has withstood wars and crises, it has seen its share of disputes:

• Baglihar Dam (2005): Resolved through World Bank-appointed neutral expert, who ruled mostly in India's favor.

• Kishanganga Project (2013): Sent to international arbitration; the court ruled that India could divert water but must ensure minimum downstream flow to Pakistan.

• Recent Developments (2023–2025): India served notice to Pakistan to modify the treaty, citing failure to resolve disputes via existing mechanisms. Talks are ongoing.

Is the Treaty in Jeopardy?

While both sides have issued strong statements and attempted legal escalations, the treaty remains intact. Most analysts agree that:

• Unilateral withdrawal is not legally feasible under international law.

• Mutual interest in water security and regional stability will continue to push both countries toward engagement rather than escalation.

• The treaty is a rare success story of India-Pakistan cooperation, and its collapse would set a dangerous precedent.

The Way Forward

The Indus Waters Treaty is a crucial framework that needs modernization to reflect climate change, population growth, and evolving needs. Some steps that can be taken:

• Technical cooperation on hydrology and data-sharing.

• Joint projects for water conservation and flood control.

• A more transparent and efficient dispute resolution mechanism.

• Mutual recognition that water cannot and should not be used as a weapon.

---

Conclusion

The Indus Waters Treaty is more than just a legal agreement—it's a symbol of the delicate balance between enmity and cooperation. While the waters of the Indus flow from India to Pakistan, the hope remains that dialogue, reason, and shared necessity will continue to flow in both directions